BoomerBoy17
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2099

 | | 14 Nov 2008 02:52 AM | | Wow, thats a nice question. Too bad i have no idea. | | | Even though I walk
through the valley of the shadow of death,
I will fear no evil,
-Psalm 23. | |
|
Nick Veteran
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1054

 | | 14 Nov 2008 09:41 AM | | :( most of that picture is a complete blur to me, even full size, beyond one triple turret its hard to make much out.
BUT, if its the same 'mystery ship' as http://i65.photobucket.com/albums/h237/kotori87/IMG_1426.jpg in your album, I'm going to go with unnamed Dutch Battlecruiser.
Not really sure though, it doesn't quite look right to me...
Edit: If I'm right, Kotori or someone else can continue asking the questions..
Edit2: I think its the Lutzow - this one in particular: http://www.westernwarshipcombat.com/chartroom/album60/Battle_105.jpg | | Running: SMS Derfflinger,
IJN Maru(oiler)
Building: SMS Moltke, Orfey Class DD
Washington Cascade Column : Model Warship Combat in the Northwest | |
|
BoomerBoy17
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2099

 | | 14 Nov 2008 12:24 PM | | Nah, its not a Lutzow. The turret on the right is to close to that end of the ship. | | | Even though I walk
through the valley of the shadow of death,
I will fear no evil,
-Psalm 23. | |
|
Nick Veteran
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1054

 | | 14 Nov 2008 12:42 PM | | I believe it is the Lutzow depicted in the 2nd image, here's my reasons:
In the underwater shot, it appears as if the bow (right hand side of the image) is suddenly cut off - but if you look closer you'll notice a grey area that matches neatly with the surface picture.
The forward turret paint schemes match.
The forward turrets angle on the bow matches to the surface shot.
In the underwater shot you can faintly make out the aft turret with matched paint scheme and angle to the surface shot. Additionally aft of that the faint image of the aft torpedos can be seen.
You can also make out the step-down to the aft deck where the torpedo launchers are located. | | Running: SMS Derfflinger,
IJN Maru(oiler)
Building: SMS Moltke, Orfey Class DD
Washington Cascade Column : Model Warship Combat in the Northwest | |
|
Nick Veteran
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1054

 | | 14 Nov 2008 12:56 PM | | There also a few things I could mention as well - photobucket provided a image date of 9-17-2006 and the automatic filename is IMG_8087. WWCC's photo gallery for the labor day events contains images labeled up to IMG_8018, a sub-gallery of 'September 17th Battle' contains images relabeled as battle_xxx and most importantly, contains an image of the ship (Carl's Spahkreuzer?) above the sunken vessel flying the same flag as in the picture - this is important because it appears to be a rarely flown flag in the albums (as in, only in this album) - Rodney and Lutzow are the only two sinks in this album that have a triple turret - given Carl's affinity for photos of sunken ships, it seems unlikely that he missed many going down - and the Rodney would look very different sitting on the bottom.
I could be completely wrong and have been completely outsmarted here, but I'm quite confident in my choice of the Lutzow. | | Running: SMS Derfflinger,
IJN Maru(oiler)
Building: SMS Moltke, Orfey Class DD
Washington Cascade Column : Model Warship Combat in the Northwest | |
|
BoomerBoy17
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2099

 | | 14 Nov 2008 03:41 PM | | alright, well, when carl logs on, he can tell us and solve the mystery. | | | Even though I walk
through the valley of the shadow of death,
I will fear no evil,
-Psalm 23. | |
|
Kotori87
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2279

 | | 14 Nov 2008 05:36 PM | | Great Job Sherlock Holmes! nwmyers, you're a veritable mystery-ship detective. Yes, it is the Lutzow. Specifically, the 1st time Lutzow went down that day, due to the caring attentions of Spahkreuzer, Cadorna, and Giussano, and a twitchy rudder servo that got wet in the first minutes of the sortie.
nwmyers, you're up! | | | There are 101 different types of people: those who understand binary, those who don't, and those who just can't count... | |
|
Nick Veteran
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1054

 | |
BoomerBoy17
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2099

 | | 14 Nov 2008 07:02 PM | | German U-120. If i got it right, cool, but im gonna be gone all weekend, so someone else come up with a question. If not, oh well, i guess i wasnt modest enough. | | | Even though I walk
through the valley of the shadow of death,
I will fear no evil,
-Psalm 23. | |
|
Nick Veteran
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1054

 | |
Gascan Veteran
 Commander
 Posts:777

 | | 14 Nov 2008 07:43 PM | | Was it U-1206? According to this [URL="http://uboat.net/boats/u1206.htm"]link[/URL], U-120 is commonly, but incorrectly, claimed to have been sunk by a toilet accident and that U-1206 was sunk due to the contributions of a deep-water toilet accident. | | | |
|
klibben Veteran
 Captain
 Posts:888

 | | 14 Nov 2008 07:50 PM | | I'm pretty sure it was 1206... | | | "We have met the enemy, and they are ours!" -Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry | |
|
Nick Veteran
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1054

 | |
Gascan Veteran
 Commander
 Posts:777

 | | 14 Nov 2008 08:42 PM | | What were the two belligerent nations in the [URL="http://www.angelfire.com/ak5/combat/Maine_.html"]Great Japanese-American Potato Fight[/URL]? Wait, never mind, that's too silly. And now for something completely different.
In the Russo-Japanese war I served on a cruiser and commanded a destroyer. I later became infamous in the fight against the Bolsheviks and recently starred in a movie. Who am I? Bonus points if you identify the ship under my command that famously blew up and sank. | | | |
|
Nick Veteran
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1054

 | |
Gascan Veteran
 Commander
 Posts:777

 | | 15 Nov 2008 11:44 AM | | The movie looks like it's got some great eye candy and a love story. Why do they always dilute a good action movie with a love story? Titanic, Pearl Harbor, Fly Boys, The Red Baron. I want to see machine guns, explosions, blood, and sinking ships, not a romantic relationship!
I've gone off the subject. Who is the guy? | | | |
|
crzyhawk
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2130

 | | 15 Nov 2008 02:26 PM | | They add that stuff in as fluff so we can talk our girlfriends into going and seeing silly movies about ships and planes! | | | HMS Invincible
USS Salem (CA-139)
USS Belleau Wood (CVL-24)
| |
|
Gascan Veteran
 Commander
 Posts:777

 | | 15 Nov 2008 09:10 PM | | Nobody is making much progress on this one, so here's a hint (especially if you read Cyrillic and speak Russian): [URL="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CjKHYENLThw"]Trailer B[/URL]
| | | |
|
Anachronus
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2183

 | | 15 Nov 2008 09:38 PM | | Still no clue but it looks like a cool movie. | | | I am prepared to meet my maker, whether He is prepared for the ordeal of meeting me is another matter.
-Sir Winston- | |
|
Nick Veteran
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1054

 | |