Kotori87
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2279

 | | 31 Aug 2008 10:13 PM | | Several months ago, somebody on the Big Gun email list pointed out that Traxxas had released a servo with o-ring seals that was labeled "waterproof". Rob acquired one of these servos, and gave it to me for testing. It worked fine in 3 feet of water, but the deep-water test was inconclusive due to failed receiver waterproofing. I then installed the servo in my miniature merchantman, saying "we'll test it when it sinks". Well, it finally happened. USS Silverfish, un-sunk since I installed the Traxxas waterproof servo, finally got sunk. They shot over it, they shot under it, they even shot into it, but nothing seemed to work. Finally, they ran it over with a battlecruiser, and that put the Silverfish down for good. Or did it?
My tiny little transport sank in approximately 8 to 10 feet of water, and stayed on the bottom for about 20 minutes before a time-out was called to recover sunken ships. When I got it back on the bench, I dumped out the water, cycled the power switch, and ran a quick systems check. Everything worked fine. The skotchkote-covered receiver was great, the geared 280 motor was fine, and the traxxas waterproof servo was working just like normal. I was back on the water within 5 minutes of getting on the bench, no maintenance required. USS Silverfish then went on to complete at least 10 more cargo laps, scoring many points for the Blue-Flag team.
Based on these results, I give the traxxas waterproof servo an "A" for its combat test, and I intend to use it in all future ships. They also have a sub-micro version suitable for destroyers. I can't wait until they come out with a micro metal-gear version for cannon depression :D
Waterproof "standard" servo: http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin/wti0001p?&I=LXTKL0&P=ML Waterproof "sub-micro" servo: http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin/wti0001p?&I=LXTKL3&P=M
-Carl
| | | There are 101 different types of people: those who understand binary, those who don't, and those who just can't count... | |
|
Bob Pottle
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1217

 | | 02 Sep 2008 10:50 AM | | Carl, Is it compatible with Futaba radios and connectors? Couldn't tell form the link.
Bob | | | |
|
jadfer
 Lieutenant Commander
 Posts:570

 | | 02 Sep 2008 01:13 PM | | Ha I was going to post asking about it today. Should we do anything more to it than stock? What about the oring on the spline? | | | |
|
Kotori87
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2279

 | | 02 Sep 2008 02:00 PM | | I didn't do any modifications to it. The spline fits Futaba servo arms. | | | There are 101 different types of people: those who understand binary, those who don't, and those who just can't count... | |
|
Bryan Veteran
 Ensign
 Posts:260

 | | 01 Oct 2008 07:39 PM | | For those in Canada Great hobbies carries them.
http://www.greathobbies.com/productinfo/?prod_id=TRX2075
Seems to be a great idea
Futaba connectors but easy to switch to JR if needed
Here is the way if any of you need end connector changes most with trimming will fit physically,just check the pins before plugging in, check the link they say it better than i will ever be able to
http://www.fatlion.com/sailplanes/servos.html
Bryan | | | Bryan, ~~
Member of the OAF, ~~
Ontario Attack Force ~~
Happy dad to battling sons. ~~
~~ http://ontarioattackforce.multiply.com/
~~ Fleet:
DKM Bismarck
SMS Hindenburg
SMS Scharnhorst
DKM Adm Scheer
DKM Nordmark
~~ Molding:
USN Tennessee
USN Gearing
IJN Mogami
IJN Akizuki
and decks turrets etc.
~~ http://ontarioattackforce.multiply.com/photos/album/18# | |
|
warspiteIRC Veteran
 Lieutenant
 Posts:451

 | | 01 Oct 2008 09:57 PM | | It already has an "O" ring on the shaft (internally). | | | |
|
Kotori87
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2279

 | | 02 Oct 2008 09:39 AM | | And o-rings around the bottom, and middle, and wires, and even around the screws. What will they think of next? | | | There are 101 different types of people: those who understand binary, those who don't, and those who just can't count... | |
|
Powder Monkey Veteran
 Rear Admiral (RDML)
 Posts:1467

 | | 02 Oct 2008 10:52 AM | | quote: Originally posted by Kotori87
And o-rings around the bottom, and middle, and wires, and even around the screws. What will they think of next?
I would say its about time [^] | | IRCWCC Fast Guns New England Task Force, http://netfrc.com USS Massachusetts BB 59 South Dakota Class Battleship Awards
2008:
Nothing But Wet, and it sure was fun 2009:
Best of scale War Ship
Ball Buster award So do or do not. There is no try | |
|
Kotori87
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2279

 | | 02 Oct 2008 09:13 PM | | I'm hoping they come up with a metal-geared micro version, suitable for the depression servo on Big Gun battleships. Standard servos are great, but only for the ships with really big barbettes. | | | There are 101 different types of people: those who understand binary, those who don't, and those who just can't count... | |
|
jadfer
 Lieutenant Commander
 Posts:570

 | | 03 Oct 2008 05:07 AM | | Carl,
Since you first bought the servo how many times has is gone beyond the traxxas '3 foot waterproof' threshold, and for how long each time?
Thanks,
Johnny | | | |
|
Kotori87
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2279

 | | 03 Oct 2008 04:38 PM | | It's been 8 feet under at least 3 times, with immersion times varying between 5 and 30 minutes. | | | There are 101 different types of people: those who understand binary, those who don't, and those who just can't count... | |
|
Evil Joker Veteran
 Commander
 Posts:615

 | | 21 Feb 2009 11:03 AM | | just received email from traxxas l
Our waterproof components are waterproof at 1 ATM.
ATM = depth of water of 33 feet. | | Southern California Region Attack Patrol (SCRAP) http://www.scrapcombatships.com
SMS Konig - Battle Ready
SMS Von der Tann - Battle Ready
DMB Scipione Africano - Battle Ready
DKM Prinz Eugen - Battle Ready | |
|
jadfer
 Lieutenant Commander
 Posts:570

 | | 21 Feb 2009 12:58 PM | | Awesome. I bought 3 but I have been told to add diving grease to them anyway. Has anyone else 'water-proofed' the water proof servos? | | | |
|
Evil Joker Veteran
 Commander
 Posts:615

 | | 21 Feb 2009 02:07 PM | | i have not 'water-proofed' and have sunk at lest 10 times with no problems | | Southern California Region Attack Patrol (SCRAP) http://www.scrapcombatships.com
SMS Konig - Battle Ready
SMS Von der Tann - Battle Ready
DMB Scipione Africano - Battle Ready
DKM Prinz Eugen - Battle Ready | |
|
BoomerBoy17
 Rear Admiral (RADM)
 Posts:2099

 | | 21 Feb 2009 04:50 PM | | i have one, thanks joker for the info. my rudder assembly will thank you. | | | Even though I walk
through the valley of the shadow of death,
I will fear no evil,
-Psalm 23. | |
|
Phill Lowe
 Ensign
 Posts:189

 | | 25 Feb 2009 04:00 PM | | I think the grease is a good idea... 1ATM is sea level, 2 ATM's is 33 feet of seawater. You still have 1ATM sitting on top of the water... Scuba Phill | | | WCC Minister of Misinformation. | |
|
Evil Joker Veteran
 Commander
 Posts:615

 | | 25 Feb 2009 04:40 PM | | opps. so maybe there good at 5 to 8 . i sink about 5 feet all the time and have had no problems | | Southern California Region Attack Patrol (SCRAP) http://www.scrapcombatships.com
SMS Konig - Battle Ready
SMS Von der Tann - Battle Ready
DMB Scipione Africano - Battle Ready
DKM Prinz Eugen - Battle Ready | |
|
Phill Lowe
 Ensign
 Posts:189

 | | 25 Feb 2009 04:48 PM | | There is much to be said about keeping your ships in 5ft of water max. I've pulled one up from 12 feet and that was tough. The problem is keeping that much weight up while you are trying to swim. Not that I want to loose the ship, but I really don't want to lose a captain. When we battle in deeper water, we insist on floats for the ships and use a rowboat for picking them up! | | | WCC Minister of Misinformation. | |
|
jadfer
 Lieutenant Commander
 Posts:570

 | | 25 Feb 2009 05:04 PM | | Does that mean that in Denver you can sink and not get wet? | | | |
|
Phill Lowe
 Ensign
 Posts:189

 | | 25 Feb 2009 05:10 PM | | I'm in Olympia, a pretty short distance out into Puget Sound will get you into 600 to 1000 feet of seawater. I'd rather battle in the settling ponds. They are gravel bottomed and usually 4-6 feet max! | | | WCC Minister of Misinformation. | |
|