Posted By Steve Tyng on 03 Feb 2012 11:15 AM
Posted By warspiteIRC on 02 Feb 2012 08:48 PM
One of the big problems that I had with CWC was it was just about impossible to get a waterline or under the waterline hit on many of the ships such as my Choctaw or the one pictured by Steve T above. So..... the superstructure would take all of the damage and that was not that easy to rebuild.
Funny how ships that were designed to be impenetrable from round shot fired at close ranges would have the same characteristics at our scales. 
So, given that "realistic" CWC means bb guns with no penetrable windows cut, just how would you score? By how many dents you put in the other guy's armor?