Hi Eric, which format will you be building for? Big Gun and Fast Gun have different recommended rookie ships, so knowing which one to advise you for will help. Anyway, to help you decide, here's a brief summary. Destroyers: unless you're joining the WWCC (unlikely, as we're on opposite coasts), a destroyer is too small for your first boat in any 1:144 scale format.
Small Cruisers: good idea for Big Gun, bad idea for Fast Gun. Big Gunners may arm torpedo cannons, which simplify plumbing and systems. Fast Gun small cruisers have to arm regular cannons, and are smaller than large cruisers, making them less suitable for rookies than larger vessels.
Large Cruisers: good idea for Fast Gun, bad idea for Big Gun. These ships are relatively roomy for Fast Gunners, and are usually faster and more agile than their prey, good for rookies. Big Gun large cruisers, however, are simply battleships writ small, so fitting all the guts in properly is difficult and maintenance is a *****.
WWI small battleship/battlecruiser: good idea for Fast Gun, bad idea for Big Gun. Again these are relatively roomy ships for Fast Gunners, and unlike cruisers, these boats can mount sidemounts for close-in slugging action. In Big Gun, these ships are again large battleships writ small, with extra turrets and fewer barrels for even more complexity and expense.
WWI large battleship: I don't know about these boats in Fast Gun, but they're not recommended for beginning Big-gunners. They're not as big as WWII battleships, and have more turrets and fewer barrels. Oh yeah, and they're slower than WWII battleships.
WWII "treaty" battleship: great for Big Gunners, again no idea for Fast Gunners. WWII treaty battleships are roomy, well-built, and have fewer turrets with more barrels. Very well-rounded ships in Big Gun.
WWII large battleship: Not a good rookie boat for either Big Gun or Fast Gun. WWII large battleships are in the 40K-50K ton range, and represent a lot of firepower and complexity in both formats. They also attract lots of attention on the pond, which requires an experienced skipper (or one who learns really fast).
WWII super battleship: Not a good rookie boat for either Big Gun or Fast Gun. WWII super-battleships like Yamato and H-39 are huge, complex, and eye-catching. Experienced skippers recommended for these. |